Burgundy 2016 – Ma–Me

Friday 5 January 2018
Angerville's Clos des Ducs

See the full guide to our coverage of Burgundy's 2016 vintage. 

 

 

DOMAINE HENRI MAGNIEN, Gevrey-Chambertin
RH: Ambitious pricing considering others in their peer group.

Cask sample. Reductive drainage aromas. Assuming these subside there is pleasant red fruit here, though nothing hugely remarkable. (RH)

Drink 2019 – 2024
£198 per case of 6 ib Haynes Hanson & Clark

Cask sample. Simple, light nose and palate with ripe but rudimentary fruit. Light tannic fur on the finish. (RH)

Drink 2021 – 2031
£340 per case of 6 ib Haynes Hanson & Clark

Cask sample. Compressed and simple on the palate with a smokier aftertaste than their other premiers crus. Tight, grainy, lean and light in structure. (RH)

Drink 2021 – 2034
£355 per case of 6 ib Haynes Hanson & Clark

Cask sample. Smoky nose with gentle red fruit that just holds up to the oak flavours. Fine tannic texture which is soft yet grippy and lovely mouth-watering acidity. Long and expressive on the finish. (RH)

Drink 2021 – 2041
£380 per case of 6 ib Haynes Hanson & Clark

Violets, blackcurrant, superbly slinky texture and long persistence on the palate. The fruit is reasonably subtle for grand cru, but there is no doubting the quality of the flavours – which are refined and polished and cerebral. (RH)

Drink 2021 – 2041
£TBC per case of 6 ib Haynes Hanson & Clark

DOMAINE MICHEL MAGNIEN, Morey-St-Denis

Cask sample. Mid crimson. Slightly leafy dark-red fruit. Light and fragrant and really pretty on the palate. Overall on the lighter side but the tannins are gentle enough to harmonise with the overall stature of this wine. Gentle but fresh pleasure. A good example of 2016’s charm. (JH)

Drink 2019 – 2024
£274 per case of 12 ib Montrachet Fine Wine Merchants

Cask sample. Mid crimson. Lightly peppery dark-red fruit. Gentle, chalky texture. A light hand in the cellar here, making the most of the more delicate fruit. Chalky finish but not particularly long. (JH)

Drink 2019 – 2025
£314 per case of 12 ib Montrachet Fine Wine Merchants

Cask sample. Mid crimson. Fragrant with sweet cherries, lifted out of the glass. Ripe but fresh. Drier on the palate than I expected, not as sweet-fruited as the aroma suggested. A bit dry and chalky on the finish. I fear the tannins will outlive the fruit if you age this too long. (JH)

Drink 2020 – 2025
£434 per case of 12 ib Montrachet Fine Wine Merchants

A blend of four premier crus.
Cask sample. Mid cherry. Lively and a touch stemmy on the nose but with the fruit still sweet and fresh. Firm and chewy on the palate, a structured Morey and not as approachable as some 2016s but all in balance for a good life ahead. (JH)

Drink 2023 – 2030
£514 per case of 12 ib Montrachet Fine Wine Merchants

 

DOMAINE SÉBASTIEN MAGNIEN, Meursault 
JR: I was more impressed by the white than the reds but the prices are tight. 

 

Quite rich but with admirable tension. This really works very well. And is not ridiculously expensive. GV (JR)

Drink 2019 – 2028
£138 per case of 6 ib Berry Bros & Rudd

A terroir quite close to Pommard, apparently.
Very deep crimson. Very ‘cool’ smelling. But for an Hautes Côtes there is more ripeness and intensity than usual. Slightly raw finish. Drying finish. (JR)

Drink 2022 – 2027
£144 per case of 12 ib Berry Bros & Rudd

More ruby and less blue than the Hautes Côtes. Light and smudgy and flattering with a baking-spice note. Slightly drying finish. (JR)

Drink 2024 – 2032

 

DOMAINE STÉPHANE MAGNIEN, Morey-St-Denis

Cask sample. Cooked cherries giving a rich and full style on the palate. Modern, forthright fruit with good spiciness on the finish. (RH)

Drink 2019 – 2026
£240 per case of 12 ib Lea & Sandeman

Cask sample. Tight, fine-grained tannins give this an austere mouthfeel with plenty of dark fruit and a glossy varnish note to finish. Quite challenging to drink young, but isn't short of fruit power. (RH)

Drink 2024 – 2034
£260 per case of 12 ib Lea & Sandeman

Heady, flattering nose. Quite intense! Then rough tough tannins on the palate for the moment but lots of vigour. May blossom as it ages in bottle? (JR)

Drink 2024 – 2030
£145 per case of 6 ib Flint Wines

Again, ripe, intense nose. In this case followed by ripe, rather luscious palate. Not the freshest but it certainly delivers ripe fruit. Would be a great restaurant buy for early delivery of pleasure. (JR)

Drink 2022 – 2030
£240 per case of 6 ib Flint Wines

Cask sample. Smoky coffee aroma with much more openness than their Grains Fins, giving a more graceful and refined structure. Well-defined cherry fruit, savoury but not austere on the finish. (RH)

Drink 2022 – 2036
£220 per case of 6 ib Lea & Sandeman

Dense, fruity and not exactly sophisticated but chock full of effort and personality. Fresh finish and presumably available only in the tinest quantity? Medium length. Good stuff! (JR)

Drink 2023 – 2032
£265 per case of 6 ib Flint Wines

Cask sample. Powerful new-oak spice on the nose, dark cherry fruit and a lot of smoky aroma through to the finish. Substantial and full-bodied without being overbearing. Needs time to knit together; the oak and the fruit are quite distinct at present. (RH)

Drink 2026 – 2046
£450 per case of 6 ib Lea & Sandeman

Not that much nose but beautifully polished tannins and vigorous fruit with a certain orange-zest character. Nothing overdone. Recommended! (JR)

Drink 2024 – 2040
£475 per case of 6 ib Flint Wines

 

DOMAINE DES MALANDES, Chablis
RH: Decent, but didn't seem to be showing their true colours.

Strong floral character, which seems almost unnatural on the nose – like pot pourri. Better balance on the palate, with green apple and pleasant yoghurt character giving breadth. The floral note returns on the finish – this is distinctive if not quite conventional. (RH)

Drink 2017 – 2021
£TBC imported by Awin Barratt Siegel Wine Agencies

More dilute than expected for premier cru, with a slightly underripe quality. Their villages Chablis is a safer bet. (RH)

Drink 2017 – 2020
£TBC imported by Awin Barratt Siegel Wine Agencies

Juicy and tight and youthful. Intense green-apple fruit with tangy herbal notes on the finish. Layered and ageworthy. (RH)

Drink 2018 – 2024
£TBC imported by Awin Barratt Siegel Wine Agencies

Crisp green fruit, punchy acidic frame, but there doesn't seem to be enough fruit concentration. More texture than flavour. (RH)

Drink 2018 – 2024
£TBC imported by Awin Barratt Siegel Wine Agencies

Creamy palate with a touch of vanilla spice, and ripe green fruit – but the overall concentration is rather lacking for grand cru. Plenty of furry texture makes this a good food match, but it doesn't scale the heights of the best grands crus. (RH)

Drink 2018 – 2024
£TBC imported by Awin Barratt Siegel Wine Agencies

 

LES VIGNERONS DE MANCEY, Tournus 

 

Lemon and crushed herbs and an attractive stony note. This is lovely: fresh, bone, bone dry and tight. A great aperitif but with enough substance for the table. GV (JH)

Drink 2018 – 2022
£5.61 per half dpd ex VAT New Generation McKinley

 

CATHERINE ET CLAUDE MARÉCHAL, Bligny-les-Beaune
EL: Claude Marechal was trained by Henry Jayer. They harvested this vintage...