Volcanic Wine Awards | The Jancis Robinson Story

Circumstance, Cape Coral Mourvèdre Rosé 2014 Stellenbosch

Friday 6 February 2015 • 2 min read
Image

From 88 rand, £8.99, €11.99, 17.90 Swiss francs

Find this wine

There is no escape from South Africa on this website this week, I’m afraid. I am determined to convince all-comers of the virtues, and particularly the value, of Cape wine today. Many of the hundreds of wines I described enthusiastically in South African excitement – reds , South African excitement – the rest and South Africa’s wild north west are definitively South African, based on blends of unusual grape varieties from old bushvines. This wine, on the other hand, is to all intents and purposes a great-value alternative to a dry, herby Bandol rosé.

It’s made from the Bandol grape Mourvèdre and has just the same very pale orangey-pink colour, the full body and the dry, food-friendly finish. This is substantial, grown-up rosé that has nothing whatever to do with anything girly, even though the highly competent winemaker is female. (According to Nadia Barnard, only about 10% of winemakers in South Africa are women.) She previously worked next door at Vergelegen and also at Flagstone but now she is chief winemaker at Englishman Paul Boutinot’s spectacular Waterkloof Estate. Nadia Barnard says she was inspired to make this wine, which has gained consistently enthusiastic notes in our database, by her time working in Boutinot’s winery in Cairanne in the southern Rhône, but I have to say that it reminds me more of a Domaine Tempier rosé than anything I have tasted in the southern Rhône.

It’s not heavy but its low acid makes it taste quite soft (residual sugar is about 4 g/l) – although there is quite enough acidity (5.1 g/l) to keep it lively. To combat Mourvèdre’s tendency to reduction, it was made in old wooden fermenters and left on the lees for a few months. It’s smoky, broad, great fun and although it’s only 12.5% alcohol, it doesn’t taste remotely puny. The 2013/14 growing season was relatively cool so that they were able to pick the grapes about 10 days later than usual, with all the necessary flavour but no excess grape sugar.

Whole bunches were pressed and only the free-run juice fermented using only ambient yeasts. Waterkloof with its award-winning restaurant overlooking Somerset West and the ocean (immediately below is my new iPhone's view from the restaurant looking east rather than south) is a biodynamic estate (certified from 2015) with Percheron horses very much in evidence.  But see the professional picture of the building at the very bottom.

The Percherons give their name to a 2011 wine of the week from Boutinot South Africa – but Paul Boutinot has now sold the operation that makes wine under the Boutinot name in space leased from Zorgvliet to the management. He now concentrates on Waterkloof, whose UK importer is also called Boutinot and operates from northern England, where Paul Boutinot grew up, in his parents’ restaurant. Got that? (You can hear Paul talking about why he chose to make wine in South Africa in this  video, shot before the winery was completed.)

The wine is available in South Africa, widely available from independent retailers in the UK, in Germany, Switzerland and the Netherlands, where, uncharacteristically, it looks rather expensive according to wine-searcher.com. The 2013 vintage is available in the US, at $16.99, from the Cape-friendly K&L of San Francisco. The fact that Richard tasted the 2014 last August and loved it just as much as I did in January 2015 encourages me to think that the 2013 may well still be fresh enough to enjoy.

Find this wine

Become a member to continue reading
Member
$135
/year
Save over 15% annually
Ideal for wine enthusiasts
  • Access 288,913 wine reviews & 15,881 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
Inner Circle
$249
/year
 
Ideal for collectors
  • Access 288,913 wine reviews & 15,881 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
Professional
$299
/year
For individual wine professionals
  • Access 288,913 wine reviews & 15,881 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 25 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Business
$399
/year
For companies in the wine trade
  • Access 288,913 wine reviews & 15,881 articles
  • Access The Oxford Companion to Wine & The World Atlas of Wine
  • Early access to the latest wine reviews & articles, 48 hours in advance
  • Commercial use of up to 250 wine reviews & scores for marketing
Pay with
Visa logo Mastercard logo American Express logo Logo for more payment options
Join our newsletter

Get the latest from Jancis and her team of leading wine experts.

By subscribing you agree with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from our company.

More Wines of the week

The Marrone family, parents and three daughters
Wines of the week An incredibly refreshing Nebbiolo from a sustainably-minded family that sells for as little as €17.50, $24.94, £22.50. - - -...
A bottle of Bonny Doon Le Cigare Blanc also showing its screwcap top, featuring an alien face
Wines of the week You need to know this guy . From $23.95 or £21 (2023 vintage). Whenever I mention Bonny Doon, the response...
The Chase vineyard of Ministry of Clouds
Wines of the week A perfectly ordinary extraordinary wine. From €19.60, £28.33, $19.99 (direct from the US importer, K&L Wines). A few months ago...
Novus winery at night
Wines of the week A breath of fresh air that’s a perfect antidote to holiday immoderation. Labelled Nasiakos [sic] Mantinia in the US. From...

More from JancisRobinson.com

J&B Burgundy tasting at the IOD in Jan 2026
Free for all What to make of this exceptional vintage after London’s Burgundy Week? Small, undoubtedly. And not exactly perfectly formed. A version...
SA fires by David Gass and Wine News in 5 logo
Wine news in 5 Also: the WHO calls for raised alcohol taxes; more tariff drama; Champagne sales decline, and protests continue at Moët Hennessy...
Ryan Pass
Tasting articles Some promising representatives of the next generation of California wine brands. Above, w inemaker Ryan Pass of Pass Wines (photo...
Aerial view of various Asian ingredients
Inside information Part five of an eight-part series on how to pair wine with Asian flavours, adapted from Richard’s book. Click here...
Vineyards of Domaine Vaccelli on Corsica
Inside information Once on the fringes, Corsica has emerged as one of France’s most compelling wine regions. Paris-based writer Yasha Lysenko explores...
Les Halles de Narbonne
Tasting articles Ninety-nine wines showing the dazzling diversity of this often-underestimated region. Part 1 was published yesterday. See also Languedoc whites –...
September sunset Domaine de Montrose
Tasting articles Tam thinks so – and has nearly 200 red-wine recommendations to show for it. Come back tomorrow for the second...
Vietnamese pho at Med
Nick on restaurants Nick highlights something the Brits lack but the French have in spades – and it’s not French cuisine. This week...
Wine inspiration delivered directly to your inbox, weekly
Our weekly newsletter is free for all
By subscribing you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.